Posted by: The Busy Post | July 13, 2012

Sebelius Claims Power to Gut Welfare Reform, Contrary to Law |

( – In a bid to expand federal welfare rolls, Health and Human Services Secretary Kathleen Sebelius claimed on Thursday that HHS had the authority to waive the key requirement in President Clinton’s welfare reform law – the requirement that beneficiaries find and maintain a job.

A plain reading of the law, however, does not seem to support this claim.

On Thursday, HHS issued what it called guidance to state welfare agencies, claiming that it could absolve states of the requirement that some welfare recipients work in order to continue receiving benefits.

HHS Sebelius at HRC event

HHS Secretary Kathleen Sebelius speaks at the release of the HRC’s Healthcare Equality Index 2012. (Photo by Judy Rolfe/HRC)

HHS claimed that its authority to approve innovative state experiments – known as demonstration projects – by issuing waivers of certain welfare requirements empowered it to waive the work requirements as well.

At issue are several sections of the Social Security Act, which governs federal welfare programs.

The waiver authority is found in Section 1115 of the law and grants Sebelius the power to issue waivers to certain welfare requirements so a state may conduct its welfare experiment. State experimentation was another key component of Clinton’s welfare reform.

“The Secretary may waive compliance with any of the requirements of section 2, 402, 454, 1002, 1402, 1602, or 1902, as the case may be, to the extent and for the period he finds necessary to enable such State or States to carry out such project,” the law reads.

In its memo, HHS claimed that a provision of Section 402 – one of the sections Sebelius has the power to waive – granted it power to get rid of work requirements.

Section 402 requires states to submit an administrative plan to the federal government, outlining how it will spend federal welfare funds and how its plan complies with the law – including the work requirement.

“While the TANF work participation requirements are contained in section 407, section 402(a)(1)(A)(iii) requires that the state plan “[e]nsure that parents and caretakers receiving assistance under the program engage in work activities in accordance with section 407.” Thus, HHS has authority to waive compliance with this 402 requirement and authorize a state to test approaches and methods other than those set forth in section 407, including definitions of work activities and engagement,” HHS said in its memo.

In other words, HHS claims that because it can relieve states of the requirement to submit a welfare spending plan to the government. It can also relieve them of the requirement that some welfare recipients must work.

However, federal law does not say this. In fact, it says exactly the opposite of what HHS claims it says.

While the law does empower Sebelius to relieve a state of the burden of providing the government a written plan, it does not empower her to waive the work requirements.

Specifically, the section of the law that governs those waivers clearly states that the waivers do not absolve states of the work requirements.

“[A] waiver granted under section 1115 or otherwise … shall not affect the applicability of section 407 to the State,” the law reads.

Section 407 is the requirement that some welfare recipients work in order to receive benefits.

The move is designed to expand welfare rolls, as HHS made clear in its memo – saying it would only issue waivers to states that planned to expand their welfare rolls.

“The Secretary will not approve a waiver for an initiative that appears substantially likely to reduce access to assistance or employment for needy families,” HHS said.

In practice, the waivers would allegedly relieve states of the requirement that certain percentages of welfare recipients work in order to remain on a state’s welfare rolls, allowing states to essentially cook their books by coming up with new ways to count people as employed who are not actually employed.

HHS lists several things states could do to earn a waiver, including counting those in vocational or other post-secondary education as working, counting people working in welfare-subsidized jobs but who are no longer receiving welfare benefits, and inventing different ways to count the disabled as working.

The proposal was met with opposition from two top congressional Republicans – Rep. Dave Camp (R-Mich.) and Sen. Orrin Hatch (R-Utah.). Camp chairs the House Ways and Means Committee, and Hatch is ranking member of the Senate Finance Committee – the committees that have jurisdiction over welfare.

Hatch and Camp sent a letter to Sebelius on Thursday demanding to know why she thinks she has the legal authority to waive welfare work requirements.

“We request that you provide a detailed explanation of your Department’s legal reasoning behind the guidance released today, as we believe it is deeply flawed and specifically contradicted by TANF (welfare) and related statutory language,” they wrote.

“Simply put, if Congress had intended to allow waivers of TANF work requirements, it would have said so in the statute,” Hatch and Camp said. “Instead, Congress did the exact opposite and explicitly prohibited waivers to section 407 work requirements among other sections of the Social Security Act.”

via Sebelius Claims Power to Gut Welfare Reform, Contrary to Law |


What are your thoughts?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s



when 140 characters is not enough

Political Alchemist's Blog

A conservative wizard's site

Which political party is promoting Abortion,Homosexuality?

As America goes, so goes the world--Praying for a spiritual renewal in America

A Patriotic Nurse

God, Country, Constitution

sharia unveiled

illuminating minds



"In a time of universal deceit - telling the truth is a revolutionary act." George Orwell

Nonoy Manga

Manga, Hand Drawn, Animation, Drawing Lessons.

The Clockwork Conservative

All wound up about politics, history, culture... lots of stuff.

Conservative First

putting principles before party and technology into politics


Absolutely, positively, and unequivocally NOT an Obamamama!

Where critical thinking is critical

The Busy Post

------ "Nowhere at present is there such a measureless loathing of their country by educated people as in America." ------ Eric Hoffer


You can see the whole Earth from the Moon!

All Mirth and No Matter

opinions on writing, reading and pretty much anything not 'rithmatic

The United States Patriot

A topnotch site


"A fool also is full of words…" -Ecclesiastes 10:14a

Amber Qalagari

Traveler. Writer. Adventure Seeker.

et cetera*

Asininities of the Human Kind

Oyia Brown

A WordPress site to share a smile; then an anthology showing how things really are.

AmeriKim Patriot

Extreme American and PROUD!

Texana's Kitchen

Yummy food. Pithy commentary. Pretty pictures.

STI News

Politics Music News Satire And Entertainment

We Moved > Go To:



people just need enough rope

Economists For Romney

Economists Supporting Mitt Romney for President

Just Cruisin 2

Where Intellectuals and Rednecks foregather.

Armor of God

Attempting to obey God and follow Jesus Christ our Lord


News , Blues and Guns ... Not Necessarily In That Order

Douglas Ernst Blog

Bare-knuckle commentary mixed with pop culture.

So I Married A Baseball Player...

Behind every married baseball player is a woman who didn't know what she was getting herself into.

living is a process please be patient with me.


at the Re-Birth of America!


Just What You Need When You're Freezing In The Dark


More Than Your Ordinary Bling

Real Life Dynamics User

Real Life Experiences With Microsoft Dynamics GP / CRM

Common Sense Newz

"The cause of America is in a great measure the cause of all mankind" Thomas Paine, Common Sense, 1776

Young, Republican, & Free

Politics; As Seen by an Eighteen Year Old Republican

The Steadfast Patriot

Where Common Sense Reigns Supreme

The Mad Jewess

Mirror Site For Reflection

Samaritans Scalawags Scoundrels Fleecing the Sheep

Skulking Down the Dirt Roads of Life

Common Sense

Life, liberty and property!


a blog for a girl who doesn't know anything

Clement Allen Photography

Updates about my gliding and photographic life will appear here.


An Amateur Economist's Perspective on the Political Battlefield

Without wax /

Andy Ritchie blog

The RAP Sheet

(opinions of that rarest of creatures: a Republican Atheist Professor)

%d bloggers like this: